Comparison
Insight Engine vs AI visibility tools
Otterly.AI and Semrush both help you see how AI assistants talk about you. Here is what Insight Engine does differently, and when another tool is the better pick.
What Insight Engine gives you
One AI Visibility Score from 0 to 100, a score for each assistant, and the three fixes that raise it most. Your Google Search score sits next to it once Search Console is connected.
- ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok and Perplexity, asked the same customer questions each week
- Each assistant's score, how often it names you, and how often first
- Ten site checks, with the fix written for you on paid plans
- Search Console and GA4 in the same place
When Otterly.AI fits better
Otterly.AI is built only for AI search visibility. If that is all you need and you don't use Google Search Console, a dedicated tool may suit you.
When Semrush fits better
Semrush is a full SEO suite with keyword research and backlink tools, and offers AI visibility features alongside them. If your team already lives in Semrush, adding its AI features may be simpler.
Check before you choose
Features and prices change. We describe the others only in broad terms; check their sites for what they offer today.
Side-by-side comparison
| Feature | Insight Engine | Alternative |
|---|---|---|
| Main number | AI Visibility Score, 0 to 100 | Each tool has its own metrics |
| Assistants asked | ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok, Perplexity | Varies by tool and plan |
| Score per assistant | Yes, with a trend line | Check each tool |
| Fixes written for you | Yes, on paid plans | Check each tool |
| Agent access (MCP server, API) | Yes, on every paid plan | Check each tool |
| Google Search Console and GA4 | Yes, read-only | Otterly.AI: AI visibility only. Semrush: its own search data |
| Free check, no account | Yes | Check each tool |
| Price | Free plan; paid from $39/mo | See their pricing pages |
Verdict
If you want one score for AI visibility, a score for each assistant, and the fixes, next to your Google data, choose Insight Engine. If you only want AI monitoring, or already pay for Semrush, one of those may be enough.
FAQ
See where you stand with AI and Google
Sign in with Google, add your website, and get your AI Visibility Score in about a minute. Free plan, no card needed.
Paid plans add all five assistants every week. See pricing